The Portland State Saturday Market was swollen with autumn: honey in hexagonal jars, apples stacked in pyramids like buildings in a city that knew how to plan, a busker playing a violin with enough sincerity to persuade you that joy is a street performer’s side hustle. The air had that October fineness, the kind that tricked you into thinking the sun might stay. Jacob wore a sweater the color of oatmeal and a hat like a blueberry. I lifted him to point at sunflowers whose faces followed us like fans.
We bought apples—Honeycrisp and one experimental variety the farmer insisted would change my life—and mushrooms that looked like an undersea creature had wandered onto the wrong table. A woman at a stand selling handmade soap told Jacob he had wise eyes. He regarded her with the solemnity newborns give to anything not a breast or a ceiling fan.
“Claire?” The name came from a voice that once lived inside my bones.
I turned. It was like a magic trick you hate: a coin pulled from behind your ear that is, in fact, your heart.
Mark stood there, his hand entwined with Emily’s the way people lace their fingers when they are trying to communicate more than togetherness. He had a beard now that made him look like a man trying on a different face. Emily’s hair was shorter, a bob that sharpened her jawline and made her look like a woman in a magazine who knows where to buy good olive oil. For a beat, the world did not remember how to be noisy.
“Hi,” I said, and I don’t know if I kept my voice from shaking because it refused or because I asked it kindly.
Mark’s eyes were not on me. They were on Jacob. He stepped from behind my leg, because it is a cruel truth that children will reveal you at the worst possible moment, and clutched his toy truck as if it were both anchor and sail. Jacob’s hair caught the light and for the first time it looked exactly like Mark’s had looked the first day of college when I met him on a campus tour and thought his smile looked like something you could write a future against.
Mark paled. The shade left his face so decisively that I saw, as if through a window, the boy he had been underneath the man. His jaw clenched with the violence of a person bracing for a wave he recognizes as his own. I felt, in that instant, an uncharitable flare of satisfaction that quickly embarrassed me. You cannot build a life on the satisfaction of someone else’s shock.
“Who…” His voice cracked. “Who is that?”
People talk about time slowing down. It does not. Our bodies speed up so fast we arrive at the answer before the question finishes. I considered lying. I considered turning away. I considered saying, “This is not for you,” which would have been true and also an evasion. I am tired of what evasion costs.
“He’s my son,” I said.
Emily laughed. It was a hard, bright sound, the door chime of a boutique in a bad mood. She looked at me, then at Mark. “Your son,” she said, and her voice rounded the words into something ridiculous. “What are the odds?”
Mark didn’t laugh. His eyes moved across Jacob’s face like hands learning Braille. Jacob’s mouth, full and intent. The particular angle at which his left eyebrow arched when he was concentrating. The dimple that only showed up when he smiled sideways, a family heirloom I had never given permission to be used.
“Claire,” Mark said, and his voice lowered into a place I had not heard since the early days when we whispered to each other in rooms that asked us to be quiet. “Is he… mine?”
Emily turned to him. “Yours?” The word clanged. “What are you—what do you mean, yours?”
Jacob looked up at me, sensing the air had sharpened. His hand tightened on my coat sleeve. “Mama,” he said, a question that only needed proximity to answer.
“Yes,” I said. I straightened my spine. I put every cell of my body between my son and the history that had made him possible. “He’s yours.”
Gasps belong in theater, but Emily gifted us one in real time. People nearby slowed with the kind of curiosity that is rude but also human. Two teenagers with cold brew hovered as if the scene were a TikTok to be dropped in a group chat later. I kept my eyes on Mark because I refused to give the crowd a better angle.
“You left me,” I said quietly. My voice found a steadiness I admired. “And I found out I was pregnant after. I didn’t tell you because you had already chosen her. I wasn’t going to drag a child into your chaos.”
Emily shoved Mark’s shoulder as if trying to push him out of his own body. The American-ness of the place we were in—the canvas tote bags with state university logos, the smell of kettle corn, the man in a Seahawks cap explaining to someone the difference between cider and juice as if that were a constitutional question—intensified the absurdity of doing this here, near a stand selling heirloom beans. A police officer wandered by with a coffee and a bored expression. He did not need to intervene. The laws we were breaking were older.
Jacob fidgeted. I crouched and pressed my lips to his hair. He smelled like rain and toddler.
“Don’t try to touch him.” I stood. Mark’s hands froze halfway between a wish and a mistake. “You don’t get to do this like a movie. You don’t get to arrive with a face and a promise and call it fatherhood.”
Mark swallowed. Tears made his eyes strange. He had always been handsome when he cried, which is a cruelty few talk about: some people look noble in pain. It makes it harder to ignore them.
“Please,” he said. “Please, Claire.”
Emily pulled her hand away. If anger is a scent, hers smelled like a match being struck and then not finding anything to light. “You knew?” she demanded. “You had a baby with her and you didn’t tell me?” Her voice went up a register that made mothers at nearby tables pull their strollers closer, instinctive, reflexive. She looked at Jacob like a mirror that refused to lie.
“I didn’t know,” Mark said, and then turned to me. “I didn’t know,” he repeated, and it sounded like a prayer you sing because you need to hear yourself sing it.
Emily stormed off. Storm is a lazy word, but there is no other verb for what she did. She became weather. It is important to say that I understood, in a small, uncharitable part of myself, that her pain was its own animal and I was not a saint for not petting it.
Mark stood in the market’s middle like a man who had looked down and found that the ground had disappeared. He looked at Jacob, then at me. “I want to be in his life,” he said. “Please. Let me try.”
I held Jacob tighter. “You made your choices,” I said, and my voice did not shake. “You don’t get to fix them by bleeding on my doorstep and calling it penance.”
I turned and walked away. I could feel Mark’s eyes on the back of my coat. The toy truck in Jacob’s fist bumped my hip. We passed the apple stand and the man selling beeswax candles, their small flames humming even in air that didn’t need them. I did not look back. I carried groceries in one bag and my son in my arms and my history in my chest like a book closed on a finger.
PART IV: The Persistent Knock
See more on the next page
Advertisement
