Persistence, it turns out, is louder than regret. He began to appear. Not like a stalker in a thriller, not in a way that would make me call the Portland Police Bureau and ask for a patrol car to swing by. More like a man trying to arrange his apology into a shape that could be seen. He waited near my apartment building’s door, hands stuffed in the pockets of a jacket I remembered him buying at a Nordstrom Rack sale, the U.S. retail blandness of it suddenly profound. He stood, careful, near the daycare entrance at pickup time, eyes on his shoes until he saw us, then lifting and softening in a way that made me angry because I had once loved that softness. He lingered at the staff lot of St. Mary’s as the sun made the brick glow and the flag out front went slack. He didn’t block me. He didn’t touch me. He asked, always, the same thing. “Please. One chance to know him.”
I refused. For weeks, I said no as if my mouth were a policeman. I texted him twice: Do not come to daycare. Do not talk to me at work. These are boundaries, not punishments. He replied: I hear you. I’m sorry. I won’t step inside the fence. I just… I’ll wait.
Rosa saw him once, standing next to his car with its out-of-state plates (he’d had a work project in Seattle; the Washington plate was an old leftover from a rental or a relocation attempt I hadn’t been told about), and she made a noise like a kettle. “I’ll have security walk you out,” she said, and I had to put my hand on her arm and say, “No, it’s okay,” because part of me did not want to escalate what I still felt was my story to manage.
He left letters. Slipped under my door in envelopes with his precise print, a discipline borrowed from an engineer father he had once cursed and then forgiven. Emails, too, with subject lines like, I understand if you don’t read this, which is the email version of a knock you apologize for after you’ve done it. He left a voicemail once at 2:17 a.m., his voice ragged, as if he’d been outside. “I know I failed you. I know I failed him. I will do what you ask. Tests, lawyers, whatever the system demands. I need to know him. I need him to know me.”
Emily, my mother told me in a phone call that began with a sigh and ended with a sentence that tried to put itself back together, had moved out. She couldn’t look at him, my mother said, because he looked at a picture he didn’t know how to frame. “She says Jacob is proof you never loved her,” my mother said, and then immediately, “I’m sorry. I know that’s not fair.”
I stood at my sink and watched the water run. American sinks have a certain low hum; the pipes in my building rattled like a throat clearing. I stared at the letter on the counter. Mark’s handwriting wavered in places that told me he’d tried to write without crying and failed. Every story we tell about people who hurt us includes a sentence where we try to make them less than human so we don’t have to include them in the census of our compassion. We say they’re monsters, cowards, narcissists, broken. Some of those words are sometimes true. But they are not enough words to do the job of naming. Mark was a man who had done something unforgivable and was now standing in the lane of a different question.
Jacob laughed in the other room at something a cartoon dog had done, the high, pure laugh that picks your heart up and shakes it like a snow globe. I thought about his future questions. Children ask with their bodies before they ask with their mouths, and I did not want to script a story for him that my fear had written.
I called a lawyer. In Oregon, family law is a bureaucracy that thinks it is a bridge: mediation, custody, child support calculations that pretended to be moral and were, in fact, math with politics. The lawyer asked if I wanted to pursue paternity testing. I did not need the swab to tell me what my eyes knew, but I wanted paper. Paper makes Americans brave. I set conditions you could build a fence with: supervised times at public places, no pickups from daycare, no unannounced visits, no posting photos. He agreed to all of it without bargaining. It is possible I made the hoop too high on purpose, just so I could watch him jump it.
The first visit was at a park where parents gathered with their strollers like a flotilla and men in Patagonia fleeces debated whether the Timbers had a shot this season while their toddlers negotiated in the language of the extremely short. The U.S. is full of parks that look like promises. Wooden play structures shaped like castles. Rubberized ground that pretends to be mercy. I arrived early with Jacob to claim a bench near an exit because control was my talisman. When Mark walked up, he looked like a man approaching a shrine. He stopped a few feet away, hands visible, as if I were a cop and he was a person who had learned to show he meant no harm.
“Hi,” he said. He did not try to hug me. He did not kneel and open his arms to Jacob the way men in movies do before someone yells, “Cut.” He waited.
Jacob clung to my leg. He watched Mark the way cats watch a vacuum cleaner: wary, ready to disappear. Mark crouched—but not close—until his knees likely protested. “Hey, buddy,” he said softly. “Cool truck.” He had brought nothing. No gifts, no stuffed animals with big heads, no elaborate peace offerings. “Can I push you on the swing?”
Jacob looked up at me. My face told him yes. I don’t know what my face said to myself.
We walked to the swings. Mark kept a respectful distance like a man who has read every article about consent and then asked someone to quiz him. He pushed the swing gently, an arc that understood the difference between fun and danger. Jacob’s laughter unstitched me. It is a cruel, perfect thing when your child’s joy has the same frequency as your pain. I watched Mark’s eyes fill and empty. He wiped them without embarrassment.
He didn’t miss a visit. It rained, and he showed up with an umbrella big enough to shelter Cleveland. It was hot, and he brought a water bottle that was exactly the kind that made moms on Instagram proud. He learned Jacob’s rhythms the way you learn a song by playing along until you stop counting. He did not overdo it. He did not perform fatherhood for me the way men perform kindness for waitstaff they want their dates to notice. He held the world the way I had always wanted him to: aware of its corner pieces first.
He did not ask me to forgive him. He never said the words “we” in any sentence that included a future. At the end of each visit, he would walk us to the edge of the park and stand with his hands in his pockets and say, “Thank you,” as if I had held a door and he had gained a room, which, if you squinted, was exactly what had happened.
Part of me waited for him to fail. Part of me rehearsed the speech I would give when he inevitably arrived late or forgot a promised Saturday. But he did not give me the relief of his failure. He gave me the burden of his consistency. It is a strange thing to resent dependability when you have prayed for it.
Rosa said, “You are doing the generous thing. Generous is not the same as easy. People confuse those and then congratulate you for suffering.” Linda said, “Make sure you keep records,” because she is the kind of woman who knows how the world punishes women who believe people will believe them.
I kept records. I kept receipts. I kept a journal with dates and weather and notes about what Jacob laughed at and what games Mark played and what questions my son asked at night with his milk breath in my face and his fingers tracing the line of my jaw as if he could find his own origin by mapping mine. In that same notebook, I wrote: generosity is a gate with a keypad. Only you know the code. People will ask for it. Do not tell them all the digits.
PART V: Supervised Sunlight
The park shifted across seasons. In winter, the swings hung heavy, rain pooling in their low, plastic seats like a dare. In spring, the cherry blossoms dumped their confetti and the city took wedding photos beneath them, joy fraying the edges of the afternoon. We stuck to the same bench most Saturdays. Routine gave our strange arrangement the dignity of a schedule. Jacob grew. He became a child with opinions about socks and bananas and which train in the children’s museum was actually the best one. He ran toward the swings now and the slide with that reckless toddler abandon that makes every parent an understudy for fear.
Mark learned him. He learned that Jacob said “blue” like “boo” and meant it. He learned that he hated puppets but loved construction paper. He learned how to engage without bribery, how to listen as if the subject were not a two-year-old’s enthusiasm for trucks but a sermon. He asked me, occasionally, logistical questions. “Is he sleeping okay?” “What do you do when he refuses food?” He did not ask me about my life inside the seams of the visit. He did not mention Emily except once, when he told me quietly that she had filed for divorce, her signature elegant and decisive.
“How is your mom?” he asked once, surprising me. It had rained that morning in a way that made the rubber flooring smell like a new tire. We sat on either end of the bench while Jacob arranged rocks into a circle he called a nest.
See more on the next page
Advertisement
