No one can take your place unless you leave it empty long enough.
They hadn’t just moved in. They’d tried to erase me.
A week after I found the card, my mother called again.
“Ethan, we’re coming up,” she announced, skipping past hello. “Your aunt says you left some things unsaid. We want to hear your side.”
It was the closest she’d come to admitting she might have been wrong about anything, ever.
“Bring a jacket,” I said. “It’s colder here than in Columbus.”
They arrived on a gray Saturday afternoon. My mom stepped out of the rental car in her church coat and sensible flats, clutching a casserole dish like a shield. My father unfolded himself from the passenger seat, rubbing his lower back, and took in the house with a slow, critical gaze the way he always did with any structure.
“You finally fixed that front step,” he said as he hugged me. “About time.”
I didn’t tell him I hadn’t fixed it—that Daniel had, probably with Lauren standing there approving the angle of the new railing. The step was solid now, regardless of whose hands had done the hammering.
Inside, the first thing my mother did was stop short at the wallpaper.
“Oh,” she breathed. “It’s lovely.”
“She picked it,” I said.
Mom’s lips pressed into a line. She set the casserole on the counter with a little more force than necessary, the lid clinking.
My aunt Carla arrived an hour later, cheeks flushed, hair sprayed into immovable waves. She swept into the living room like she’d been invited to a funeral she didn’t want to attend but couldn’t afford to miss.
“Ethan,” she said, kissing the air near my cheek. “I hope you know none of us approve of how you treated Daniel.”
“Good to see you too,” I replied.
We didn’t dance around it. There wasn’t any point.
After coffee and a few minutes of small talk that tasted like cardboard, I led them into the dining room. The DVR sat in the center of the table like a bomb.
“What’s that?” Mom asked.
“The truth,” I said.
I connected it to the small TV on the sideboard and pressed play before anyone could object. Sunlight flooded the screen. Lauren’s laughter filled the room again, but this time it wasn’t just bouncing around in my chest. It was echoing off the walls with three other people there to hear it.
My mother’s hand flew to her mouth when Daniel appeared, coming up behind Lauren to wrap his arms around her. Aunt Carla started to say something—some automatic defense of her son—but the words died as the footage went on.
They watched the pancakes and the kisses and the grocery bags carried in through my front door. They watched the way Daniel dropped his keys in the bowl by the entry like he owned the place. They watched Lauren pad through the living room in my sweatshirt.
And then they heard it.
“He won’t come back,” Lauren said on the screen. “He never comes back.”
My father’s jaw muscle ticked at the same time my own did.
I let the clip play to the end, then paused it on a frame of them laughing together on my couch, my throw blanket tangled around their legs.
“You want my side?” I asked, keeping my voice level. “There it is.”
For a long beat, no one said anything.
“You… you should have told us,” my mother said finally, her voice thin.
“When?” I asked. “Before I had proof and you all accused me of being paranoid? Or after, when you’d already chosen a narrative where I was the villain for changing the locks on two squatters?”
Her shoulders slumped. She looked smaller suddenly, every year of her age settling into the lines around her eyes.
“He’s still my nephew,” Aunt Carla whispered, as if saying it quieter made it more reasonable. “I can’t just… cut him off.”
“I’m not asking you to,” I said. “You can love him all you want. Bake him casseroles. Pay his parking tickets. Just don’t expect me to stand there and pretend nothing happened.”
“Family is all we have,” she snapped back, some of her usual fire returning.
“Then he should have treated me like it,” I said.
Dad, who’d been silent the entire time, cleared his throat.
“Carla,” he said, turning to his sister, “if one of my kids pulled this on yours, you know exactly what you’d call them. And it wouldn’t be ‘family.’”
She flinched.
“He’s lost,” she muttered. “He makes stupid choices. But he’s not evil.”
“Lost is when you can’t find your way home,” I said. “He knew exactly where home was. He just decided it belonged to him.”
Silence settled over the table again. Outside, the wind shifted, sending a deeper roar through the trees. The house seemed to breathe with it.
Eventually, my mother reached across the table and laid her hand over mine.
“I’m sorry,” she said. “I shouldn’t have called and yelled at you. I didn’t know.”
It wasn’t everything. It wasn’t enough to erase the sting of hearing her defend Daniel before she’d even bothered to ask what had really happened. But it was something.
“Now you do,” I replied.
They stayed the night. I gave them the guest room—the one Lauren had always said we’d turn into a nursery someday. My mother stood in the doorway for a long time before going in, her fingers resting on the frame.
“You’ll fill this room with something better,” she said quietly.
I didn’t answer. I wasn’t ready to think about filling anything yet.
After they left Sunday afternoon, the house was quiet again. But it was a different kind of quiet than the one that had followed Lauren and Daniel’s retreat. That silence had been heavy with anger and leftover lies. This one felt… open. Like a page that had finally been cleared of someone else’s handwriting.
I started with small projects.
I fixed the leaky faucet and replaced the cracked tile by the back door. I hauled a warped bookshelf out to the garage and sanded it down, the smell of sawdust clinging to my clothes. I walked the property line with a mug of coffee in hand, memorizing the way the fence posts leaned and the blackberry brambles clawed over the edges.
The neighbors began to wave again.
For months, they’d kept a careful distance, giving polite nods without stopping to chat. I didn’t blame them. No one wants to get caught in the crossfire of someone else’s domestic mess.
One evening, as the sky blushed pink over the water, my next-door neighbor, a retired high school teacher named Frank, wandered over while I was reinforcing a loose railing on the deck.
“Saw your folks here last weekend,” he said, leaning on the post as if testing my work. “Looked like quite the summit meeting.”
“Something like that,” I said.
He scratched his cheek, hesitating.
“Listen,” he added. “I owe you an apology too. I saw your ex-wife and your cousin here a lot this past year. I figured you knew.”
“Most people did,” I said. “I was the only one pretending not to.”
He huffed a dry laugh.
“They weren’t exactly discreet,” he went on. “I’d be out walking the dog, and there they were, arguing about paint colors in the driveway like they were on one of those home makeover shows. My wife kept saying, ‘It’s none of our business, Frank.’ So I kept my mouth shut.”
“You did the right thing,” I said. “If I’d been ready to know, I would’ve asked.”
He studied me for a moment.
“You look better,” he said finally. “Last time I saw you out here, you looked like a man watching his own house burn down. This time you look like the guy holding the hose.”
“Something like that,” I repeated.
After he left, I sat on the deck and watched the sky go from pink to purple to black. The waves crashed against the shore in a rhythm I felt in my chest. I thought about all the years I’d spent trying to be steady for everyone else—Lauren, Daniel, my family—building things for them to stand on while they quietly chipped away at the beams.
I’d been so focused on being a good husband, a good cousin, a good son, that I hadn’t noticed I’d stopped being a good guard for myself.
No one can take your place unless you leave it empty long enough.
I’d left too many doors unlocked. Too many keys on the table.
So I started locking a few.
I called my bank and tightened every access point on my accounts. Two-factor authentication, security codes, alerts for even the smallest transactions. I rewrote my will. I sat down with my lawyer again and restructured the business so that no one—not a future partner, not a relative, not even a spouse—could move pieces around without my explicit consent.
It wasn’t about becoming paranoid. It was about learning from what the house had tried to teach me.
Months passed. The trees along the driveway flushed green, then gold, then bare. Tourists came and went from the little town down the road, clogging the diners on summer weekends and leaving behind plastic cups and sand-covered flip-flops. The house settled around me like a coat that had finally been tailored to fit.
Sometimes, when the wind was just right, I’d catch the faint scent of the floral wallpaper glue if the sun hit the living room wall at a certain angle. It was like the ghost of Lauren’s dream following me room to room. I let it.
I could have ripped it down. I could have painted over it in a single weekend, wiped away the last visible trace of her. But I didn’t. The pattern stayed, soft and beige and deceptively gentle.
It reminded me that you can’t always tell by looking who built the life you’re walking into—or who paid for the walls around you.
One November afternoon, as rain hammered the roof in steady sheets, I sat at the dining table with my laptop open, not to check footage this time, but to plan.
For the first time in a long time, I wasn’t planning around anyone else’s wants.
I wrote out three columns on a blank document:
What stays.
What goes.
What I build next.
See more on the next page
Advertisement
