I stood up.
“To let you keep using me. To keep paying your bills while you treat my home like it’s yours.”
“It practically is ours,” Jessica snapped, standing as well. “We’ve been living there for two years. We’ve made it our home. Just because your name is on some piece of paper doesn’t mean you own everything.”
“Actually,” I said, my voice ice cold, “that’s exactly what it means. That piece of paper is called a deed. And it means I own the house. Not you. Not Robert. Me.”
Robert moved between us, his face flushing red.
“Mom, Jessica didn’t mean—”
“Yes, she did.”
I looked at my son.
Really looked at him.
“This was never about reconciliation, was it? This was about getting me to drop the lawsuit. Making me feel guilty enough to let you stay without any real consequences.”
“We came here in good faith,” Jessica said, her voice rising. “We brought muffins. We’re offering to pay rent. What more do you want from us?”
“I want my house back,” I said. “I want you out.”
“You ungrateful—” Jessica caught herself again, breathing hard. “Do you know what we’ve sacrificed for you? Living with you. Dealing with your moods, your demands, your constant presence in our marriage. We gave up our privacy, our space, our freedom to take care of you.”
“Take care of me?” I laughed, a sound without humor. “You spent my money, took my home, and threw me out. That’s not caregiving. That’s exploitation.”
Robert’s face was scarlet now.
“You know what, Mom? Fine. We tried. We came here to be the bigger people—to extend an olive branch—and you spit on it. Don’t expect us to try again.”
“I won’t,” I said.
“And don’t expect to ever meet your grandchildren,” Jessica added venomously. “You want to be alone? You want to destroy this family? Fine. But you’ll die alone, and Robert and I will tell our kids that their grandmother was a selfish, bitter old woman who chose money over family.”
The words were designed to hurt.
And they did.
But I didn’t let it show.
“Get out of my hotel room.”
They left, Jessica slamming the door hard enough to rattle the frame.
I stood in the silence they left behind, shaking.
But standing.
Through the window, I watched them argue violently in the parking lot. Jessica was gesturing wildly, screaming something at Robert, who looked defeated and small.
I sat down on the bed and let myself shake.
Let myself feel the fear, because I was afraid.
Afraid of being alone.
Afraid I’d destroyed my relationship with my son forever.
Afraid I was making a terrible mistake.
But beneath the fear was something else.
Certainty.
I’d seen their true faces now—stripped of pretense.
Jessica’s rage.
Robert’s weakness.
Their willingness to manipulate and threaten.
This wasn’t family.
This was a toxic relationship I needed to escape.
I called Daniel, my voice steady.
“They just tried to get me to drop the lawsuit in exchange for a promise to pay $500 a month in rent.”
“Did you record it?” he asked.
“Every word.”
“Excellent. That actually strengthens our case. It shows their bad faith. See you in court Wednesday.”
“See you in court.”
After I hung up, I ate one of the blueberry muffins they’d brought.
It tasted like victory.
The courtroom was smaller than I expected—wood-paneled, formal, smelling of old paper and furniture polish.
I sat beside Daniel at the plaintiff’s table, my hands folded calmly in my lap.
Across the aisle, Robert and Jessica sat with Marcus Patterson, their attorney.
Jessica wore a conservative dress and pearls, playing the part of the respectable daughter-in-law.
Robert looked haggard—dark circles under his eyes.
Good.
Judge Patricia Morrison entered, a woman in her sixties with steel-gray hair and sharp eyes that suggested she’d heard every story and believed none until proven.
“This is the matter of Anderson versus Anderson and Collins, case number 2024-CV3847. Let’s proceed.”
Daniel stood.
“Your Honor, this is a straightforward unlawful detainer case. My client, Margaret Anderson, owns the property at 1847 Oakmont Drive. The defendants, Robert Anderson and Jessica Collins, have been residing there without paying rent. Mrs. Anderson properly served a 30-day notice to quit. The defendants have refused to vacate. We’re asking the court to order their immediate eviction.”
Marcus Patterson stood, his voice smooth.
“Your Honor, this is not a simple eviction. This is a family matter involving elderly abuse, manipulation, and a mother’s attempt to illegally dispossess her son from what has become his family home.”
“Mr. Patterson,” Judge Morrison said, “does your client have any legal right to the property? Is his name on the deed, the mortgage, any ownership documents?”
“No, Your Honor, but—”
“Then we start with the premise that this is Mrs. Anderson’s property. You may proceed with your defense, but the burden is on you to demonstrate why your clients should not be evicted from property they don’t own.”
I watched Patterson’s confidence waver slightly.
“Your Honor, we intend to prove that Mrs. Anderson has been mentally incompetent, that she coerced the defendants into accepting financial assistance and then used that assistance as leverage to maintain control over them.”
Judge Morrison looked at me, studying.
“Mrs. Anderson, do you suffer from any mental health conditions?”
I stood.
“No, Your Honor. I had a complete psychiatric evaluation performed by Dr. Sarah Wittmann three weeks ago specifically to address these claims. I have documentation.”
Daniel handed the report to the bailiff, who delivered it to the judge.
She scanned it quickly.
“This shows no cognitive impairment whatsoever. Mr. Patterson, do you have any medical evidence to support your claims?”
“We have testimony from witnesses about her erratic behavior, Your Honor.”
“I’ll hear it. Call your first witness.”
Patterson called Jessica.
She took the stand, dabbing at her eyes with a tissue.
“Your Honor, I love Margaret. She’s been like a mother to me. But over the past year, we’ve watched her decline. She became forgetful, paranoid. She’d accuse us of stealing from her when we’d done nothing wrong. She’d forget conversations we’d had. We were genuinely worried about her.”
“Miss Collins,” Judge Morrison interrupted, “if you were so concerned about Mrs. Anderson’s mental health, did you seek medical intervention? Take her to a doctor? Contact adult protective services?”
Jessica blinked.
“We… we tried to encourage her to see someone, but she refused.”
“And yet you continued to live in her house and allow her to pay your bills,” the judge said. “We were trying to help her. We stayed because we were worried about her living alone.”
“While spending her money on your car payments, student loans, and credit cards,” the judge said, her voice dry. “How altruistic.”
Daniel stood.
“Your Honor, I’d like to enter into evidence bank statements showing over $80,000 in payments made by Mrs. Anderson on behalf of the defendants over a two-year period. Also, a recording from six days ago where the defendants attempted to manipulate Mrs. Anderson into dropping this lawsuit.”
He played the recording.
In the silent courtroom, Jessica’s voice rang out clearly.
“Just because your name is on some piece of paper doesn’t mean you own everything.”
And later:
“You’ll die alone, and Robert and I will tell our kids that their grandmother was a selfish, bitter old woman who chose money over family.”
Judge Morrison’s expression hardened.
“That’s enough. Mr. Patterson, does your client have anything to say that actually provides a legal defense to this eviction?”
Robert took the stand—his lawyer’s desperate last attempt.
“Your Honor, she’s my mother. She offered to help us. We didn’t force her to do anything. Now she’s angry about some misunderstanding, and she’s using her ownership of the house to punish us—to destroy our family.”
“Mr. Anderson,” the judge said, her voice cold, “did you or did you not tell your mother to pack her belongings and leave her own house because your in-laws needed her room?”
Robert hesitated.
“I… it wasn’t like that exactly.”
“It’s a yes or no question.”
“Yes, but—”
“And did you or did you not contribute financially to the mortgage, utilities, or property taxes on this house?”
“We contributed in other ways. We maintained—”
“Yes or no, Mr. Anderson.”
“No,” he said, not directly.
“But Mom offered—”
“Mr. Anderson,” Judge Morrison said, “your mother didn’t offer to be displaced from her own home. She didn’t offer to have you threaten her with isolation from future grandchildren. I’ve heard enough.”
Judge Morrison turned to Jessica and Robert, her expression severe.
“You two have engaged in what I can only describe as financial elder abuse, followed by constructive eviction of the property owner. The fact that Mrs. Anderson is your mother makes this worse, not better.”
Jessica started to speak, but the judge held up her hand.
“I don’t want to hear it, Miss Collins. Your recording speaks for itself.”
Judge Morrison looked at her notes, then delivered her ruling.
“I find in favor of the plaintiff, Margaret Anderson. The defendants are ordered to vacate the property at 1847 Oakmont Drive within seven days. If they fail to do so, the sheriff will remove them and their belongings. Furthermore, Mrs. Anderson is awarded court costs and attorney fees.”
She paused, looking directly at Robert.
“Young man, I suggest you spend some time reflecting on how you’ve treated the woman who gave you life. Dismissed.”
The gavel struck—final and absolute.
I watched Robert and Jessica’s faces as the reality sank in.
Jessica’s carefully constructed composure shattered.
She turned on Robert, her voice a harsh whisper I could hear across the courtroom.
“This is your fault. You said she’d never actually follow through. You said we could manipulate her.”
Robert looked broken, staring at his hands.
Marcus Patterson gathered his papers quickly, clearly wanting to escape.
“I’ll be in touch about the appeal process.”
“Don’t bother,” Jessica snapped. “This was a waste of money.”
As they filed out of the courtroom, Jessica shot me a look of pure hatred.
Robert wouldn’t meet my eyes.
Outside in the hallway, Daniel shook my hand.
See more on the next page
Advertisement
