“I do not know that either, sweetheart. But no matter what, you and I are a family.”
To help her understand different family structures, I created a storybook with pictures and simple text explaining how families come in all shapes and sizes. Some kids live with grandparents, some with two moms or two dads, some with just one parent, and some, like Lily, with an aunt who loves them more than anything in the world.
My parents maintained their distance, visiting perhaps three or four times a year, always with the same tension and criticism. My mother would bring gifts that were often inappropriate for Lily’s age or interests, demonstrating how little she paid attention to who her granddaughter actually was.
“She should be in ballet by now,” my mother would comment, bringing yet another tutu for a child who preferred dinosaurs and building blocks. “All the girls in the neighborhood are taking lessons.”
My father remained emotionally unavailable, asking surface-level questions about Lily’s schooling but never engaging in play or meaningful conversation with her. His anger at Amanda seemed to have calcified into a general coldness toward all of us. Lily, sensitive and perceptive, would become quieter during their visits, her natural exuberance dimmed by their lack of warmth.
My personal life remained largely on hold during these years. Dating as a single mother was complicated enough, but dating as someone in my unique situation seemed nearly impossible. The few men I met through friends or work who seemed promising would inevitably pull back when they understood the full picture of my commitment to Lily.
I chose to focus on her needs rather than pursue relationships that might bring more instability into our lives.
Our support network continued to grow. I joined a single-parents group that met monthly, finding solidarity and friendship with others navigating similar challenges. Lily formed close bonds with the children of my friends from work, creating a chosen family that celebrated holidays and milestones with us.
Financial stability remained a constant struggle. I took on a second job doing telehealth nursing consultations two evenings a week after Lily was asleep to build a college fund for her future. It meant less sleep for me and careful budgeting. But the growing savings account gave me peace of mind that I could provide long-term security for her.
After years of careful saving, we took our first real vacation when Lily was six, a trip to Disney World that she still talked about years later. Watching her face light up as she met her favorite characters made every extra shift and budgetary sacrifice worthwhile. We returned with a photo album full of memories and a renewed appreciation for our daily life together.
Lily’s artistic talents began to emerge around this time. Her kindergarten teacher noted her unusual attention to detail in drawings, and I encouraged this interest with art supplies and museum visits whenever possible. She would spend hours creating elaborate pictures of our adventures, real and imagined, that captured the special bond between us.
As I approached the five-year anniversary of Lily’s arrival in my life, I found myself reflecting on how completely my existence had transformed. My apartment was filled with children’s books instead of novels. My refrigerator displayed spelling tests instead of social invitations, and my schedule revolved around school events and playdates.
None of it resembled the life I had planned, yet I could not imagine wanting anything different.
In a box under my bed, I kept letters I had written to Amanda over the years but never sent, having no address to send them to. They documented Lily’s milestones, her funny sayings, her growing personality—things a mother might want to know. Sometimes I wondered if Amanda ever thought about the daughter she had left behind, if she regretted her decision, or if she had found whatever she was looking for when she drove away that rainy night.
“Look what I made for you, Nana!” Lily called, interrupting my thoughts as she ran into the kitchen, holding a carefully drawn picture of two figures, one tall and one small, surrounded by a large red heart.
“That is beautiful, sweetie,” I said, pulling her into a hug. “Is that us?”
“Yes, that is you and me inside a heart because we are a heart family, not a blood family. Miss Peterson told us that some families are made from blood and some are made from heart, and heart families are just as real.”
“Miss Peterson is very wise,” I said, blinking back tears. “We are definitely a heart family.”
“And that is the best kind,” Lily declared with the absolute certainty only a five-year-old can possess.
I hung the picture on the refrigerator alongside her other masterpieces, a visual reminder of what we had built together out of the most unexpected beginning.
Four more years passed in a comfortable rhythm of school years, summer breaks, holidays, and the everyday moments that form the foundation of a family life. Lily was nine, thriving in fourth grade with good friends and a passion for both art and science that kept her curious mind engaged. She had grown into a thoughtful, resilient child with my sister’s artistic talent, but a steadiness of character that was entirely her own.
The phone call came on an ordinary Tuesday evening as I was helping Lily with her science project about the solar system. An unknown number flashed on my screen, which I almost ignored, assuming it was a telemarketer. Some instinct made me answer instead.
“Hello?”
“Hello, Natalie.”
The voice was hesitant, familiar, yet strange after so many years.
“It is Amanda.”
My hand tightened on the phone as I stepped quickly into my bedroom, away from Lily’s curious eyes.
“Amanda, where are you? Are you okay?”
“I am fine. I am actually in town. I was hoping we could meet. To talk.”
We arranged to meet at a café the next day while Lily was at school. I spent the night alternating between anxiety, anger, and a strange sense of relief that she was alive and well. I told Lily I had a doctor’s appointment, hating the small lie but knowing I needed to understand Amanda’s situation before involving her daughter.
The woman who walked into the café was almost unrecognizable from the troubled sister I remembered. Amanda was 32 now, her hair styled in a sophisticated bob instead of the wild curls of her youth. She wore a tailored blazer and carried an expensive-looking handbag. She looked healthy, put together, worlds away from the overwhelmed young mother who had left her baby on my doorstep a decade ago.
“You look good,” she said as she sat down across from me. “Really good.”
“You, too,” I replied, studying her face for traces of the sister I had once been close to. “You seem well.”
“I am,” she said, twisting her hands nervously despite her composed appearance. “I have been sober for seven years now. I completed rehabilitation, got my degree in graphic design, and I am married to a wonderful man named Thomas.”
She proceeded to tell me a story of recovery and redemption. After leaving Lily with me, she had spiraled further into drug addiction, living on the streets of San Diego for a time before hitting rock bottom and checking herself into rehabilitation. There she met Thomas, a counselor, and after completing her program and maintaining sobriety, they had eventually married. They had no children of their own.
“I was not fit to be a mother,” she admitted. “I was using heavily during my pregnancy, though I tried to stop. I was terrified the baby—that Lily—would have health problems because of me. When she seemed okay, I thought I could handle it. But the postpartum depression hit hard, and I went back to using. The night I brought her to you, I had been using for days. I knew I was going to hurt her if I kept her. Leaving her with you was the only good decision I made during that time.”
I showed her photos on my phone of the childhood she had missed—Lily’s first steps, first day of preschool, kindergarten graduation, birthday parties, Halloween costumes, Christmas mornings. Amanda wiped tears as she swiped through the evidence of a decade of absence.
“She is beautiful,” she whispered. “So beautiful and clearly happy. You have done an amazing job, Natalie.”
My emotions were chaotic—a mixture of the old anger at her abandonment and a new cautious hope that perhaps Lily could have a relationship with her birth mother after all. We talked for hours, carefully navigating a decade of separation and the complex reality of our situation.
“I would like to meet her,” Amanda said finally. “If you think that would be okay.”
After careful consideration and consultation with a child psychologist, I arranged the first meeting between Amanda and Lily. I prepared Lily by explaining that my sister, her birth mother, had been very sick when Lily was a baby, but was better now and wanted to meet her. I emphasized that nothing would change about our life together, but that Amanda might become a part of our extended family, like an aunt.
The meeting took place at a neutral location, a children’s museum, where Lily could feel comfortable and engaged if the interaction became overwhelming. Lily was uncharacteristically shy, clinging to my hand as Amanda approached with a nervous smile.
“Hello, Lily,” Amanda said softly. “I have been looking forward to meeting you for a long time.”
“Hi,” Lily replied, half hiding behind me. “Nana says you are her sister.”
“That is right. And I am also your birth mother, which means you grew in my tummy before you were born.”
Lily nodded solemnly.
“But Nana is my real mom because she takes care of me and loves me and helps me with homework and makes me soup when I am sick.”
Amanda’s eyes filled with tears, but she smiled bravely.
See more on the next page
Advertisement
