My name is Claire Morgan , and until last month I would’ve described my marriage to Ethan as “steady.” Not perfect, not dramatic—just normal. We both worked, split bills, and tried to keep up with life in a small suburb outside Columbus. Ethan had always been a little flashy when his sister Madison came around, though. Madison and her husband Tyler were the kind of couple who treated every weekend like a photoshoot—new shoes, new gadgets, dinners that cost more than my car payment. Ethan would roll his eyes about them when they weren’t around… and then try to impress them the second they arrived.
That Friday, I left for a two-day training in Cincinnati. Ethan said he’d stay home, “catch up on chores,” maybe meet Madison and Tyler for lunch. I didn’t think twice. I kissed him goodbye, threw my overnight bag in the trunk, and drove out.
Sunday evening, I got home exhausted and hungry. Ethan was on the couch, oddly energized, scrolling through his phone with a smirk that didn’t fit the quiet living room. Madison and Tyler were gone, but I could still smell someone’s cologne and the sugary perfume Madison loved. When I asked how the weekend went, Ethan leaned back like he’d been waiting for me to ask.
“Honestly?” he said, grinning. “Great time. Madison and Tyler were a blast.”
I dropped my bag by the door. “Nice. Did you guys just do dinner or what?”
He laughed and held up his hands like he was presenting a trophy. “Baby… thanks for your card.”
At first, I thought he was joking. Ethan liked teasing, and I assumed he meant I’d left him my debit card for groceries. “My card?” I asked.
He said, smug. “Your ATM card. We went on a little spree.”
My stomach tightened. “Ethan, stop. What are you talking about?”
He shrugged. “We treated ourselves. You know, shopping, a couple nice dinners, a weekend trip. Nothing crazy.”
I stared at him. “How much?”
He squinted at the ceiling like he was doing mental math he already knew the answer to. “Around…fifty grand.”
The room went cold. My heartbeat turned into a loud thud in my ears. “Fifty thousand dollars? Ethan, that’s not funny.”
He grinned wider, like my panic was part of the entertainment. “Relax. It’s fine. You’ll see.”
I didn’t answer. I walked straight to the kitchen counter where my purse sat, unzipped it, and pulled out my wallet with shaking fingers. I slid my debit card out and held it up.
“Really?” I said, forcing the words through a tight throat. “Because it’s sitting in my wallet.”
Ethan’s smile died instantly. His eyes flickered from the card to my face, and the color drained out of him.
“What?” he whispered.
I watched his hands go still on his phone, his mouth slightly open like he’d forgotten how to breathe. And then I noticed something on my screen as I opened my banking app—a notification I had never seen before:
“New card activated.”
For a second, I didn’t move. I just stared at the notification, the words blurry because my eyes were filling with hot, angry tears. My fingers hovered over the screen as if touching it would make the truth real. Ethan sat frozen on the couch, watching me with the same expression you’d see on someone who just realized the “joke” wasn’t funny anymore.
I tapped into the account details. A list of transactions loaded—high-end stores, designer retailers, hotel charges, a jewelry purchase that made my throat tighten, and multiple cash withdrawals. The total at the top wasn’t “around fifty grand.” It was $52,318.74.
My voice came out quieter than I expected. “How did you activate a new card?”
Ethan swallowed. “I… didn’t. I mean—”
“Don’t,” I snapped, loud enough that he flinched. “Don’t lie to me. Not now.”
He stood up, palms open like he could calm a storm. “Claire, listen. It was just temporary. I was going to pay it back.”
“With what money?” I asked, stepping away from him like his words were contagious. “And why would you need a new card to do it?”
Ethan dragged a hand down his face. “I ordered a replacement. Online. I said the original was damaged.”
See more on the next page
Advertisement
