“You need to grow up,” he said, pointing at me like a judge. “Stop thinking only about yourself and start thinking about what’s best for the family.”
“No,” I said, grabbing my coat from the back of the chair. “I think it’s time you started thinking about what’s fair. And what’s best for me.”
The kids went quiet. Melissa’s mouth parted like she wanted to say something but couldn’t find the words. Dad’s face was flushed a deep, dangerous red.
I walked out.
I drove home with my fingers gripping the steering wheel so tightly my knuckles ached. When I stepped back into my own house, the quiet hit me like a wall. No clinking plates. No raised voices. Just the soft hum of the fridge and the creak of the floor under my feet.
My phone buzzed.
Melissa: You’re selfish. Mom would be so disappointed if she saw how you were acting.
A voicemail from Dad followed shortly after.
“I hope you’re happy,” his voice said. “You’ve really shown your true colors tonight.”
I stared at the phone, then set it face down on the counter.
The word selfish had been thrown at me so many times it almost didn’t sting anymore. Almost. But this time, it wasn’t just about saying no to a favor or refusing to babysit or declining to lend money. This time it was about the one thing that represented years of my life.
My house.
I wandered from room to room, seeing everything through a new lens. The couch I’d bought after months of comparison shopping. The paint colors I’d agonized over. The crooked desk I’d built. The bed I’d assembled alone at midnight, cursing the instructions.
I thought of Mom again.
Of the night on the back porch when she had called me outside after dinner, a glass of iced tea in her hand, the air thick with the sound of cicadas.
“Come sit with me,” she’d said.
I’d been home from college for a few days, my head full of finals and internships and the ticking clock of adulthood. She’d seemed quieter than usual that week, like her thoughts were somewhere far away.
We sat side by side on the old porch swing, the chain creaking softly as we swayed.
“I want you to know something,” she said, staring out at the dark line of trees at the back of the yard. “You’re not responsible for everyone else’s happiness. It’s not your job to fix everything.”
I had laughed then, a quick, nervous sound.
“Feels like it sometimes,” I said.
She smiled, a small, sad curve of her mouth.
“I know it does,” she replied. “Your father leans on you. Melissa leans on you. Sometimes I do, too. But that’s because you’re capable, not because it’s your duty. There’s a difference.”
I filed the words away without fully understanding them.
Then she’d taken a breath, deeper this time, like she was gearing up for a leap.
“There’s something else I need to tell you,” she said. “Something you might not understand now, but someday you’ll know what to do with it.”
My stomach had flipped.
“Okay,” I’d said.
“It’s about Melissa,” she said.
My mind immediately jumped to a hundred possibilities—health problems, money problems, something about her latest boyfriend.
“What about her?” I asked.
Mom’s hands tightened around her glass.
“She’s not your father’s daughter,” she said quietly.
The world tilted.
“What?” I whispered.
“I had an affair,” she said, her voice barely audible over the hum of the cicadas. “Years ago. Before you were born. Your father and I were in a bad place. I didn’t think we’d make it. I made a mistake.”
She swallowed hard.
“By the time I realized what I’d done, I was pregnant,” she continued. “Your father assumed Melissa was his, and I let him. I told myself it didn’t matter because he loved her. Because I loved her. Because telling the truth would destroy everything.”
My chest had felt tight, like I couldn’t quite take a full breath.
“He doesn’t know?” I asked.
She shook her head.
“He doesn’t know,” she said. “And I don’t think I can be the one to tell him. I’m telling you because I can’t leave this world with you in the dark. You deserve to know the truth.”
I had been twenty then, barely able to manage my own life, suddenly holding a secret that felt heavier than anything I’d ever carried.
“What am I supposed to do with that?” I asked.
She looked at me, her eyes shiny with unshed tears.
“Maybe nothing,” she said. “Maybe you’ll never need to do anything with it. But if the day comes when you have to choose between protecting a lie and protecting yourself…” She trailed off, then squeezed my hand. “I want you to choose yourself.”
For years, I chose the lie.
I watched Dad dote on Melissa, calling her “my girl” with a tenderness he rarely aimed in my direction. I watched him make excuses for her when she dropped out of classes, when she quit jobs, when she chose the wrong men.
When Melissa got pregnant at twenty-two and her boyfriend bolted, Dad stepped in without hesitation. He helped her find an apartment. He paid for a nanny. He co-signed for a car so she wouldn’t have to take the bus.
“She needs me,” he said when I asked why he wouldn’t help me buy a used car for my internship.
“You don’t,” he’d added. “You always figure it out.”
He said it like a compliment.
It didn’t feel like one.
I carried Mom’s secret like a stone in my pocket, always aware of its weight, never quite sure when—if ever—I was allowed to drop it.
Now, standing in my kitchen with my phone buzzing itself to exhaustion on the counter, listening to my father and sister tell me I was selfish for not giving up my house, I realized something.
Maybe the day Mom had warned me about—the day I would have to choose—had arrived.
The next time Dad called, I picked up.
“Finally,” he said, exasperation already threaded through his voice. “I was starting to think you were ignoring me.”
“What do you want, Dad?” I asked.
“What do you think?” he snapped. “I want you to do the right thing. Melissa needs your help, and you’re acting like it’s some kind of personal attack.”
“Because it is,” I said. “You’re asking me to give up the one thing I’ve worked for because you think she deserves it more. Do you hear yourself?”
“She’s struggling,” he said, softening his tone the way he always did when he thought he could reason me into submission. “You’re in a position to help. It’s not that complicated.”
I took a breath.
“You’re right,” I said. “It’s not that complicated. So let me make this simple for you.”
Silence.
“Melissa is not your daughter,” I said.
The quiet on the other end of the line was so complete I wondered if the call had dropped.
“What are you talking about?” he said finally, his voice low and strained.
“Mom told me,” I said. “Years ago. Before she died. She had an affair. Melissa isn’t biologically yours.”
“That’s ridiculous,” he said, but there was a tremor underneath the words. “She wouldn’t—your mother wouldn’t—”
“She did,” I said. “And she never told you because she thought it would destroy you. But if you’re going to keep throwing her name around to guilt me into giving up my house, then maybe it’s time you knew the truth.”
For a long time, he didn’t say anything.
When he finally spoke, his voice was barely audible.
“I need time to process this,” he said.
“Take all the time you need,” I replied. “But stop blaming me for a situation that isn’t mine to fix.”
I hung up before he could answer.
My hands shook as I set the phone down. My legs felt unsteady, like I’d run a marathon I hadn’t trained for.
The secret was out.
There was no putting it back.
The days that followed were strangely quiet. My phone didn’t buzz as often. No new voicemails from Dad, full of disappointment. No fresh crop of guilt-laden texts from Melissa.
The silence was both a relief and a weight.
I went to work. I came home. I tended to the small potted herbs on my kitchen windowsill, pinching off dead leaves, watering the soil with a care I struggled to extend to myself.
Every time my phone lit up, my heart lurched. Most of the time it was junk mail, a work email, a group text from friends about dinner plans.
I found myself half hoping, half dreading another call from Dad.
It wasn’t Dad who broke the silence.
It was Melissa.
She called late one night. Her name glowed in the dark room as I lay in bed, staring at the ceiling.
Against my better judgment, I answered.
“How could you say something like that?” she screamed before I could say hello.
I winced, pulling the phone away from my ear.
“Melissa, calm down.”
“Calm down?” she repeated, incredulous. “You told Dad I’m not his daughter. Do you have any idea what you’ve done?”
“Yes,” I said. “I told him the truth. Something Mom should have told him.”
“You had no right,” she hissed.
“And what about my rights?” I shot back. “Do you think I enjoy being the one who’s always expected to sacrifice everything for you? You’ve been the center of Dad’s world your whole life, Melissa. Have you ever wondered why? Why you got everything handed to you while I had to fight for every scrap?”
Silence.
For a second, I thought she might actually say something real. Admit she’d noticed. Admit it had bothered her, too.
Instead, she hung up.
The next morning, the family group chat lit up like a Christmas tree.
Cousins I hadn’t seen since somebody’s wedding suddenly had opinions.
How could you do that to your dad? one wrote.
Some things are better left unsaid, an aunt added.
You’ve always been a little selfish, but this takes the cake, another chimed in.
Selfish. Always selfish.
See more on the next page
Advertisement
