Can Jane come with us to see mommy? Benjamin looked at Jane. She was already shaking her head, backing away. No, I shouldn’t. That’s private. That’s for your family. You are family, Mick said simply. The words hung in the air. Benjamin didn’t know what to say. Taking Jane to Amanda’s grave felt wrong, like crossing a line he couldn’t uncross, like betraying something sacred.
But his sons were looking at him with those wide, hopeful eyes. And Jane was standing there, terrified she’d ruined everything. if she wants to come. Benjamin heard himself say she can. Jane’s eyes went wide. Benjamin, are you sure? No, he wasn’t sure, but he nodded anyway. An hour later, they stood together at Amanda’s grave.
Benjamin, Jane, and three little boys who didn’t understand why love had to be complicated. The boys placed their angel card on the headstone. Then they stepped back quiet. Mick reached for Jane’s hand and pulled her forward. Tell mommy you’re nice,” he whispered. Jane knelt at the grave, tears streaming down her face. “I hope you don’t mind that I love them,” she said softly.
“I’m not trying to replace you. I just I couldn’t help it.” Benjamin stood behind her, his throat too tight to speak. Rick whispered to the headstone, “Mommy, Jane makes good pancakes and she plays with us and she doesn’t get sad when we talk about you.” That last line broke something in Benjamin. He’d been the one getting sad, the one pulling away, the one making his sons feel like loving someone new meant forgetting their mother. Jane stood, wiping her eyes.
She met Benjamin’s gaze and something passed between them. Understanding, forgiveness, permission to keep living. 2 months after that day at the cemetery, Benjamin went to a charity gala at the Greenwich Country Club. He didn’t want to go. He’d been avoiding these events since Amanda died. But his mother-in-law, Patricia, was on the planning committee, and she’d insisted, “You can’t hide forever, Benjamin. People want to see you.” So, he went.
The room was full of familiar faces, people who’d known Amanda, people who’d sent flowers after the funeral and then never called again. They smiled at him now, polite and distant, like he was something fragile they didn’t know how to touch. Harrison Blake, a fellow tech CEO, approached with his wife, Vanessa.
“Benjamin, good to see you out,” Harrison said, shaking his hand. “How are the boys?” “Better,” Benjamin said. “Much better, actually.” Vanessa smiled, but there was something sharp behind it. “Yes, I heard you found wonderful help.” “What’s her name again?” Warning bells went off in Benjamin’s head. “Jane Morrison,” he said carefully.
and she’s been quite devoted to the children from what I hear,” Vanessa continued, her voice dripping with false sweetness. “She’s excellent at her job.” Vanessa exchanged a look with Harrison. “Of course, I just think it’s wonderful that she’s so involved. Some might say unusually involved for household staff.” Benjamin’s jaw tightened.
“I’m not sure what you’re implying.” “Nothing,” Vanessa touched his arm. “Just that people talk. There was a photo of you all at the farmers market last week. The boys holding her hands, you pushing the cart. It looked very domestic. We were buying groceries. Of course, Vanessa said, but you know how people are.
A young woman, a widowerower, three impressionable children. She trailed off meaningfully. Harrison cleared his throat. What Vanessa means is maybe consider the optics. For the boy’s sake, Benjamin’s voice went cold. The boys are happy for the first time in 8 months. That’s the only optic I care about. He walked away, his hands shaking.
But over the next week, the whispers grew louder. Someone wrote a blind item in the local society column. Which widowed tech titan is getting too comfortable with the help? A photo appeared online. Jane and the boys at the playground laughing. The caption read, “Nanny,” or something more.
Then the call came from Brookfield Academy, the private preschool where he’d enrolled Rick, Nick, and Mick for the fall. The headm’s voice was apologetic, but firm. Given the recent attention, and considering the sensitivity of our other family’s concerns, perhaps it’s best if the boys start next semester instead. Benjamin gripped the phone. You’re rejecting my sons because of gossip.
We’re protecting all our students from unnecessary scrutiny. My children are being punished for having someone who loves them. Mr. Scott, please understand. Benjamin hung up. His chest felt like it was caving in. Not because of the school. He could find another school, but because he knew what this meant. Jane would hear about this. She’d see the articles.
She’d know she was the reason his sons were being rejected. And she’d leave. He drove home faster than he should have, his mind racing. When he got there, he went straight to Jane’s room in the guest cottage. The door was open and she was packing. Her suitcase lay open on the bed, half filled with clothes.
She moved mechanically, folding shirts, placing them inside. Benjamin stood in the doorway. Frozen Jane, she turned. Her eyes were red. I can’t stay, she said quietly. I’ve become the problem. Don’t. Benjamin’s voice came out rough, almost desperate. Jane kept folding clothes, her hands trembling. I have to. Your sons were rejected from school because of me.
Because of gossip, because of people who don’t matter. They matter to Rick, Nick, and Mick. Her voice cracked. They’re going to grow up hearing whispers. They’re going to be punished because I forgot my place. Your place? Benjamin stepped into the room. Your place is with my sons.
Jane shook her head, tears falling onto the shirt in her hands. I’m the maid, Benjamin. That’s all I was supposed to be. You stopped being the maid the day my son started laughing again. Then what am I? She turned to face him, her eyes fierce and broken. What am I supposed to be to them? To you? Benjamin opened his mouth, but the words stuck in his throat. Jane let out a bitter laugh. You can’t even say it because the truth is, I’m black.
I’m young. I’m staff. And people will always make assumptions. Your sons will pay the price their whole lives if I stay. Let them assume. I don’t care what they think. You should care. Her voice rose. Rick, Nick, and Mick deserve better than being the center of scandal. They deserve better than than what? Than someone who loves them.
Than the only person who made this house feel like home again. The silence between them was electric. Jane sat down on the edge of the bed, her shoulders dropping. When Hope died, she whispered, “I promised myself I’d never love another child because losing her almost killed me.” “But your boys,” she looked up at him, tears streaming. “I couldn’t help it.
And now I have to leave before loving them destroys me.” Benjamin knelt in front of her, his heart pounding so hard it hurt. “What if you didn’t have to leave? The scandal? What if I told the truth publicly? What if I made it clear you’re not just staff?” Jane’s eyes searched his face.
What truth? That you’re essential? That my children need you? He stopped, swallowed hard. That I need you, too. Her breath caught. Benjamin, not as a maid, not as a nanny. As someone who understands this grief, someone who sits in the dark with me when I can’t sleep. Someone who brought light back into a house that was dying. I’m not her, Jane whispered. I’ll never be Amanda.
I know, Benjamin’s voice broke. And I’m not asking you to be. I’m just asking you to stay because when I think about you leaving, when I think about this house without you in it, I can’t breathe. Jane covered her face with her hands, sobbing. Benjamin stayed on his knees, waiting, terrified she’d say no. Finally, she looked at him. If I stay, it can’t be like this.
I won’t hide. I won’t pretend to be less than I am. I don’t want you to. Your world won’t accept me. Then my world needs to change. Jane stared at him for a long moment, something shifting in her eyes. I’ll stay, she said quietly. But not as your employee, as myself. All of myself. I wouldn’t want it any other way. She stood and he stood with her. For a moment, they just looked at each other.
Two broken people who’d found something fragile and real in the wreckage. Jane reached out and unpacked her suitcase, and Benjamin finally breathed. The week after Jane unpacked her suitcase, something shifted in Benjamin. He stopped hiding.
He’d scheduled an interview with the Wall Street Journal weeks ago, standard publicity for a new product launch. His PR team had prepared talking points about cloud infrastructure and market expansion. Safe topics, corporate topics. But when the reporter arrived at his office, Benjamin had different plans. Diana Chen sat across from him, recorder running, asking the expected questions. Benjamin answered them automatically, his mind somewhere else. Then Diana paused, glancing at her notes. Mr.
Scott, if I may shift gears, there’s been some public interest in your personal life lately. Would you care to comment? His PR director, standing by the door, gave a sharp shake of his head. Don’t engage. Benjamin ignored him. What specifically? He asked. Diana hesitated. The speculation about your relationship with your children’s caregiver. The old Benjamin would have said no comment.
Would have ended the interview right there. But sitting in that chair, he thought about Jane packing her suitcase, about his son’s faces when they thought she might leave. About Rick, whispering to Amanda’s grave that Jane didn’t get sad when they talked about their mother. “Yes,” Benjamin said. “I’d like to comment.” Diana’s eyebrows rose.
“Jane Morrison is the reason my sons are alive in the ways that matter,” Benjamin said, his voice steady. After their mother died, they stopped talking, stopped playing, stopped being children. I hired specialists, therapists, tried everything money could buy. Nothing worked. And then then Jane showed up. She didn’t try to fix them. She just loved them. She got on her hands and knees and played horse.
She read them stories. She sat with them through nightmares. She gave them permission to heal. Some have suggested the relationship is inappropriate, Diana said carefully. Benjamin’s jaw tightened. Some people see a young black woman caring for three white children and automatically assume something improper.
That says more about them than it does about her. So, the relationship is strictly professional. Benjamin paused. This was the moment. Jane Morrison is family. He said, “She’s not their mother. No one could replace Amanda, but she’s someone they love, someone they need, and I won’t apologize for having her in our lives. Even if it costs opportunities for your sons.
Any institution that rejects my children for being loved by someone who doesn’t fit their narrow definition of acceptable has no business raising them. The interview went live the next morning. By noon, it had gone viral. Half the internet praised his honesty, his defense against prejudice.
The other half tore him apart, accused him of using his privilege, of romanticizing the help, of moving on too quickly. His board called an emergency meeting. Benjamin walked into the conference room to find 12 faces staring at him with concern. The optics are problematic, his CFO began. I don’t care about optics, Benjamin said. I care about my family. This could affect stock prices.
Then let them fall. I built this company. I’ll run it my way and I won’t compromise my son’s happiness for shareholders. The room went silent. That evening, Benjamin came home to find Jane in the kitchen, her laptop open, tears on her face. She was watching the interview.
You didn’t have to do that, she said, her voice breaking. Yes, I did. He sat beside her. Because every time I stay silent, someone else tells our story and they get it wrong. Your board is angry. They’ll survive. You could lose everything. I’ve already lost everything that mattered once, Benjamin said quietly. I won’t lose it again. Not without a fight.
Jane looked at him, something shifting in her eyes, something that looked like wonder and fear and gratitude all mixed together. She stood and stepped toward him. Then she did something she’d never done before. She hugged him, not professionally, not carefully, fully, like someone holding on to a lifeline. and Benjamin held her back, his eyes closing, feeling less alone than he had since Amanda died.
Maybe this was what Grace looked like. Two broken people choosing each other in the wreckage. 6 months passed. The whispers didn’t stop completely, but they quieted. Some people came around, others didn’t. Benjamin stopped caring which was which. What mattered was happening inside his home. Rick started speaking in full sentences again. Nick’s smile came back the real one, not the polite one he’d been using since the funeral.
Mick stopped having nightmares every night. They called Jane Mama Jane. Now, it had started organically, their own compromise between honoring their mother and loving the woman who’ brought them back to life.
See more on the next page
Advertisement
