“Everything,” she said vaguely. “The house, Lucas’s future, how we move forward. I think I’ve found a solution that works for everyone.”
Her confident smile suggested she was convinced she had made an offer she couldn’t refuse.
The restaurant she chose was deliberately impressive—minimalist decor, small portions, and prices that sent shivers down your spine. Sophia was already seated at the table when I arrived, looking elegant in a designer dress that somehow suggested a tasteful, mournful mood while remaining fashionable.
“Eleanor, thank you for coming,” she greeted me, kissing my cheek. “I ordered us a bottle of Veuve Clicquot. James always said it was your favorite.”
It wasn’t. James knew perfectly well that I preferred a simpler Chardonnay, but this artificial intimacy was part of her performance.
“How nice,” I murmured, settling into the chair, something I rarely allowed myself to do, even before James died.
Nevertheless, she poured the champagne and toasted, raising her glass.
“Towards new beginnings and solutions.”
I politely sipped, waiting for her to create the atmosphere she desired: sociable, cordial, warm, and intimate. The manipulation was textbook: create a pleasant environment, establish rapport, suggest a shared understanding before presenting your offer.
“Eleanor,” she began as our appetizers arrived, “the last few weeks have been very difficult for all of us. Losing James, trying to help Lucas cope, and grappling with all the practicalities.”
I nodded encouragingly, playing my part.
“I’ve been thinking about what’s truly important,” she continued, her voice taking on a practiced sincerity. “Family. Safety. Peace of mind. And I think I’ve found a way for all of us to have what we need.”
“I’m listening,” I said, cutting off a small piece of my overpriced scallop.
“We both know James’s will has created complications.” She delicately sipped her champagne. “The house, the vehicles, the bills. It’s all rather awkward, isn’t it? It’s not at all what James would have wanted if he were thinking clearly.”
I remained silent, allowing her to continue speaking uninterrupted.
« I spoke with an excellent probate lawyer. He believes we could easily contest the will, given James’s mental state in recent months, the stress he was under, and the medication he was taking for a pre-existing heart condition. Proving diminished legal capacity wouldn’t be difficult. »
My heart sank as I heard her casually suggest overturning my son’s will, but I kept my face neutral.
« I see. »
« But litigation is so unpleasant, » she continued smoothly. « It’s divisive, dragging on for months, even years. That’s not what Lucas needs right now. »
“Absolutely not,” I agreed, wondering where this show was going.
She leaned forward and spoke, lowering her voice conspiratorially.
« So I came up with a better solution. One that would give us both what we wanted without any tedious legal battles. »
“What will that be?” I asked, genuinely curious about her strategy.
« Transfer the house and vehicles back to me, as James’s widow, » she explained, as if offering a huge favor. « In return, I’ll guarantee you regular visits with Lucas. Maybe every other weekend, on major holidays. I’ll even put it in writing. »
The breathtaking audacity of her offer to essentially buy out my grandson almost unnerved me. She was proposing that I give up everything James legally left me in exchange for « permission » to see Lucas’s rights, which I already had as his grandmother.
“That’s a pretty good offer,” I managed, taking another sip of champagne to hide my reaction.
“I know, it’s so generous,” she agreed, misinterpreting my hesitation as concern. “Most women in my shoes would fight for everything, but I value your relationship with Lucas. And honestly, sometimes I could use your help.”
“Sometimes,” I repeated, catching on to the apt choice of words.
“Well, single motherhood is demanding,” she sighed dramatically. “And I have a career to think about. Besides, Richard and I…” she paused, trying to regain her composure. “I mean, I’ll eventually want to rebuild my personal life. Providing childcare would be incredibly helpful.”
That was the real motivation. Not Lucas’s well-being, but convenient childcare that would allow her to develop her relationship with Richard without interruption.
“What about Lucas’ trust fund?” I asked innocently. “Will it stay the way James arranged it?”
A flash of irritation crossed her face, then she smiled again.
« This is also unnecessarily complicated. As his mother, I should have control over his educational expenses. Children’s changing needs require flexibility. »
“Of course I do,” I agreed, thinking of all the times Lucas’s needs had been ignored in recent weeks.
« So, » she said, reaching into her purse and pulling out a folded document, « I let my lawyer draw up a simple agreement. You transfer the assets back to where they belong. I guarantee you visitation rights. Pure, simple, everyone wins. »
She slid the paper across the table with the confidence of someone who thinks they have everything in their hands. I took it, scanning the language that would effectively undo everything James had orchestrated to protect Lucas and me.
“That’s quite detailed,” I commented, buying myself time to formulate a response. “What about Arizona? Will Lucas and I still be able to visit each other if you move?”
« Speaking of which, » she said, a look of regret on her face. « The Arizona move might become more permanent. Richard has opportunities there, and there are great private schools for Lucas. It would be a fresh start for everyone. »
And conveniently, far away from me and from anyone who knew James or might have had doubts about her upbringing.
From my perspective, the elements of her plan fell into place perfectly.
“I need to think about it,” I said, folding the document and putting it in my purse. “And maybe I should have Thomas look at it, since he knows James’s wishes.”
Her smile grew wider.
« I wouldn’t involve Thomas. He’s pretty old-fashioned about these things. My lawyer assures me it’s completely standard procedure. »
“I’m sure you will,” I replied gently. “Still, such an important decision deserves careful consideration. James always taught me never to sign anything without checking it thoroughly.”
She couldn’t object to James’s advice without being accused of disrespect, so she just smiled and gestured for the check.
« Of course, it will take a few days. But Eleanor, » she added, her voice taking on a subtle edge, « this really is the best solution for everyone. Arguing with me on this would only hurt Lucas in the long run. »
A thinly veiled threat hung between us as she paid for our pricey meal with a credit card I suspected was James’s. I maintained a thoughtful facade, thanking her for the dinner and promising to « give her proposal the attention it deserves. »
Driving home, I finally allowed my hands to shake on the steering wheel. The brazenness, the manipulation, the nonchalance with which she planned to separate Lucas from his remaining connections to James—all of it confirmed what I’d been documenting for weeks.
I called Thomas from the car.
“She plans to take Lucas to Arizona permanently,” I said bluntly. “And she offered me a devil’s bargain to get her house and accounts back.”
“Perfect,” Thomas replied, surprising me. “Just what we needed. Bring the document to my office tomorrow morning. Time to move on to the next phase.”
During an expensive dinner, Sophia revealed her true colors, proposing a devilish deal: I’d give her everything James had left me in exchange for letting me see my own grandson. Her plan to move Lucas to Arizona with her lover revealed her intent on erasing James from their lives. Little did she know, her transparent manipulation had provided us with exactly the evidence we needed. Thomas’s cryptic response suggested the game was about to change, and Sophia had no idea what was about to happen.
« She really wrote this. I can’t believe it. »
Thomas Bennett shook his head in astonishment as he looked through the document Sophia had given me. The next morning, we sat in his office, the coffee cooling, as we analyzed her proposal.
« It’s basically an admission of guilt, » he continued, marking sections with a yellow marker. « She clearly states that she will only allow you to see Lucas if you hand over assets that legally belong to you. This is a classic example of coercion. »
“And the part about Arizona,” I said, pointing to the provision about “reasonable visitation regardless of place of residence.”
“She establishes a deliberate intention to separate Lucas from his support system and familiar surroundings during his grief,” Thomas added, adding another point. “Combined with the evidence we’ve gathered about her parenting patterns, this creates a compelling narrative.”
I leaned back in my chair, considering the consequences.
“What will happen now?”
Thomas put down the marker and his expression became serious.
« It’s time to implement the contingency plan James had prepared. He hoped it wouldn’t be necessary, but he had prepared for exactly this scenario. »
From his desk drawer, Thomas pulled out a sealed envelope marked « Emergency Protocol » in James’s handwriting. My heart sank at the sight of my son’s familiar handwriting.
“James left detailed instructions on when and how to proceed if Sophia’s behavior threatened Lucas’ well-being or attempted to separate him from you,” Thomas said, carefully opening the envelope. “A key element is an emergency custody modification request.”
“Change custody?” I repeated, stunned. “James wanted me to file for custody of Lucas?”
“Temporary custody, to begin with,” Thomas explained. “Based on the documented evidence of parental neglect and the best interests of the child during this grieving period, James believed, and I agree, that the judge would likely grant you temporary custody until a more permanent arrangement can be established.”
My hands were shaking slightly. The responsibility James had given me was enormous—not only documenting Sophia’s behavior, but also potentially taking over care of Lucas.
« I’m sixty-five years old, Thomas. Would a court really consider me the guardian of Lucas’s mother? »
« Age is not a disqualifier, especially considering your involvement in his life. And remember, we are not arguing that Sophia is an unfit mother in the traditional sense. We are arguing that her current priorities and choices are negatively impacting Lucas’s emotional well-being during a critical period of grief and adjustment. »
Thomas presented us with the evidence we had gathered: my detailed journal documenting Sophia’s absences and Lucas’s reactions; home surveillance footage showing numerous disturbing incidents; statements from Lucas’s teachers about missed conferences and unfinished homework; notes from his grief counselor about regression and anxiety that coincided with Sophia’s increased absences; photographic evidence from the trip to Miami with Richard while Lucas stayed with the hotel staff, and now an incriminating document intended to use Lucas as leverage.
« We’ll need one more element, » Thomas explained. « A neutral, independent assessment of Lucas’s home environment and emotional state. I’ve arranged for a court-approved child psychologist to speak with Lucas at his school tomorrow. Standard procedure in such cases. Nothing that would alarm Sophia if she found out. »
The methodical way James prepared for this eventuality, even to the point of finding the right psychologists, broke my heart again. How long had he been worried about Sophia’s upbringing? How much had he seen before deciding such drastic measures might be necessary?
“When should we file the petition?” I asked, trying to focus on practical matters rather than my turbulent emotions.
“Immediately after receiving the psychologist’s report, assuming it confirms our position, likely within forty-eight hours.” Thomas’s expression softened slightly. “Eleanor, are you prepared for what happens next? Sophia won’t let this go. She’ll be furious. Possibly vindictive.”
I thought of Lucas’s small face when he returned from Miami. How he’d confided in me that his mother had left him overnight with strangers, how he’d clutched a photo of his father, trying not to cry. I thought of James, who had foreseen this situation and trusted me to protect his son when he couldn’t anymore.
“I’m ready,” I said firmly. “What’s our next step?”
« Maintain your current attitude toward Sophia. Don’t let on that anything has changed. If she presses for an answer regarding her proposal, tell her you’re still considering it and have questions about certain details. » Thomas began organizing the documents in his folder. « In the meantime, I’ll prepare a motion for immediate dismissal and consult with a psychologist. »
As I was leaving Thomas’s office, my phone vibrated and a message from Sophia appeared on the screen.
I need an answer by tomorrow. Arrangements are underway in Arizona. This is a crucial opportunity for Lucas’ future.
The transparent attempt to create a false sense of urgency only strengthened my resolve. I typed a carefully calibrated response.
I’m still browsing. I have a few questions about the appointment schedule. Can we talk tomorrow evening?
Her reply came immediately.
Good. 7:00 PM at home. Richard’s attorney will be present to answer any questions.
Richard’s attorney. Not James’s. Not a neutral party. Not even her own, independent attorney. Another crucial detail for our documentation.
I spent the afternoon after school with Lucas, helping him with his homework and listening to him reluctantly describe the incident from the morning when Sophia forgot to make him lunch and then scolded him for calling to remind her because she was in an « important meeting. » I jotted these details down in my journal right after he went upstairs to play, noting his dejected demeanor and the way he dismissed his mother’s reaction—clearly accustomed to dealing with her emotions, not his own.
That evening I received an unexpected call from Thomas.
« The school psychologist met with Lucas at lunch today, » he informed me. « Her initial findings are significant. Lucas exhibited increased anxiety when discussing his home environment, a particular fear of being sent to Arizona, and a clear attachment to you as his primary source of emotional support. »
“Is that enough?” I asked, and hope slowly began to rise within me.
« In conjunction with our other evidence, yes. Tomorrow morning I will file a motion for an emergency hearing. The judge I requested usually rules on such cases within twenty-four hours. »
“Should I tell Lucas anything?” I worried about whether I could prepare him for the potential turmoil.
See more on the next page
Advertisement
