It was a quiet Sunday afternoon in Brookhaven, Vermont. Four-year-old Leo Hart was rolling his toy truck across the carpet when he suddenly said, “My real mother is in the well.”
His adoptive mother, Nora Hart, froze mid-stitch. “What did you say, sweetheart?”
Leo looked up, calm and serious. “She wore a blue dress. She fell into the well in our backyard. Daddy Patrick was there.”
Nora’s husband, Patrick, lowered his newspaper with a scowl. “He’s making up stories again,” he said sharply. But a chill crept up Nora’s spine—because there was an old well beneath the garden, sealed long before Leo ever came home.
Over the next days, Leo repeated the same thing. He drew a woman with long dark hair in a blue dress, falling into a black circle. Each picture tightened a knot in Nora’s stomach.
When she mentioned it to her neighbor Erin, the woman waved it off.
“He’s from the orphanage. Kids spin tales, Nora. Don’t overthink it.”
But Leo’s details were too precise. When Nora asked where he’d heard about the well, Leo said quietly, “I remember it. Daddy Patrick said not to tell.”
That night Nora lay awake. She replayed Patrick’s odd insistence on adopting that specific child and the adoption agent’s thin, incomplete paperwork.
One evening, she pulled out the file again. The pages were poor photocopies with missing signatures. The social worker’s name—Michael Voss—led nowhere online. It was like he’d never existed.
When Nora confronted Patrick, his face flushed. “Why are you digging? You think a four-year-old knows truth from fantasy? Stop it.” He flung the file to the floor and stormed out.
Nora stared at Leo’s newest drawing—this time, the woman’s face had tears. In the corner, the boy had scrawled: “She’s still waiting.”
The next morning, Nora decided to dig—literally.
She waited until Patrick left for work, then called a local handyman, Ted Ramirez. “I just want to check beneath the old well cover,” she said, trying to sound casual. Ted hesitated, then agreed for double pay.
When the concrete cap finally gave way, a foul odor rose up. Nora staggered back. “Probably an animal,” Ted muttered, shining a flashlight.
A beat later his voice shook. “Ma’am… you should call the police.”
Scraps of blue fabric lay tangled in the dirt—beside something pale that looked human.
Detective Isla Chen arrived within the hour. “Who found this?”
“I did,” Nora said, trembling. “My son kept saying someone was in the well.”
The yard was sealed off. Patrick came home to flashing lights and yellow tape and erupted. “What is this?”
Detective Chen’s tone was even. “Mr. Hart, we need to ask you some questions.”
The week unfolded like a nightmare. The medical examiner confirmed the remains belonged to a woman who died about twenty years earlier. Near the body, they found a rusted bracelet engraved R.A.
Leo, too young to grasp it all, whispered to Nora, “Mom will be happy now.”
Patrick denied everything. “I bought this place years ago. Never saw a well.” But property records showed he had once employed a live-in maid named Ruth Avery—missing since 2004.
Cold dread washed over Nora. In the digital archives, she found an old headline:
“Local Woman Vanishes—Domestic Dispute Suspected.”
The photo showed a smiling woman in a blue dress beside a white picket fence. Behind her, half-hidden, was Patrick.
Confronted with the image, Patrick’s hands trembled. “It was an accident,” he whispered. “She fell. I tried to help.”
See more on the next page
Advertisement
